Introduced in 1898. Discontinued in 1908. Cyclist No. 1 is a pleasing design, examples of which appear for sale with some regularity (see a detail of the design, below). This back design is easier to find in its US8d iteration, and blue decks are offered for sale more frequently than red ones. Finding any Cyclist No. 1 deck in an original box would be highly unusual.
SALES DATA
A VG+ red US8d Cyclist No. 1 deck (no joker/no box) sold on eBay for $121 on October 12. 2016.
A VG+ blue US8d deck (no joker/no box) sold on eBay for $76 on November 15, 2016.
A VG blue US8b deck (no joker/no box) sold on eBay for $89 on May 10, 2017.
A G/VG- blue US8d Cyclist deck (no joker/no box) sold on eBay for $21 on June 25, 2017.
An EX blue Cyclist No. 1 deck in US8d box (no joker) sold on eBay for $425 on September 9, 2020. An original box makes all the difference!
A pair of red and blue Cyclist No. 1 singles sold on eBay for $5 on August 16, 2025. I tend to not make note of common cards that sell for under $10, but this is a very low price for a pair of such singles.